Payroll Watchdog
Comparison

Checkr vs Sterling

Pricing modelper-checkcustom-quote
Starting pointPlans reportedly run from about $29Quote-based contracts
Best forUS-based small and mid-size employers who want background checks built into their existing hiring software.Mid-size and larger employers in regulated industries, or anyone whose hires span countries where shallow database checks don't exist.
CountriesUnited StatesUnited States, Canada, United Kingdom, Australia, India
Editorial score8.4/107/10

Checkr

Pros
  • Fastest, most reliable turnaround of the mainstream US background check providers
  • Integrates directly into most popular hiring stacks, minimal manual work
  • Built-in compliance workflows for adverse action notices
Cons
  • Roughly double Certn's entry price for a comparable basic check
  • US-focused, not the right choice if you're vetting contractors or hires abroad
  • Package/pricing structure can be confusing to compare against competitors up front

Sterling

Pros
  • International criminal coverage that leads the industry in several markets
  • Document-based identity verification integrated into screening, not bolted on, which is the fraud-relevant part
  • Deep compliance tooling for regulated industries where screening errors carry legal cost
Cons
  • Acquired by First Advantage in late 2024, long-term platform and integration roadmap is an open question
  • Quote-only pricing with volume commitments, hostile to occasional screeners
  • Overbuilt and overpriced for straightforward US SMB hiring
United StatesCanadaUnited KingdomAustraliaIndia